how did they fuck up the rares, those rares would never be rare because of the amount of people hoarding em, did you really expect something that happened with rs3 (people pk'ing with rares because they're useless), huge amounts of people losing these rares and eventually ending up with only a small amount of rares in the economy, guess what, not going to happen.
and also they didn't "fuck up", the players had the choice and this is what 75%+ wanted :c